You’re twisting my arm, here…

“Manipulation” is a logically untenable sin. Think about it: if I tell you I like ice cream, I am trying to make you believe I like ice cream. In short, I am trying to manipulate you. All social interaction is attempted manipulation.

If you wish to say that it’s a matter of degree, then consider this: if someone falls off of a cliff, and I use my spider-powers to catch them safely in a net, I am physically forcing them to do what I want them to do – survive – without first asking them. Extreme manipulation indeed, and yet I will be praised rather than cursed for it. If I write a novel, I am trying to manipulate the emotions of my readers as much as possible, and that is what they are paying me to do. They want me to force them to laugh and cry. If I bring my wife flowers and poems, I am trying to make her feel happy and affectionate, and yet she does not object.

Alright, you say. It’s a matter of intent.

I agree. And there’s the rub:

Every act of evil manipulation that exists exists because it is also an act of hate, or lust, or covetousness. In fact, there is always in action another sin entirely, perhaps several. But then why bother accusing someone of manipulation? Instead, accuse him of hate, or lust, or covetousness. The motive is evil, but the actions themselves are, well, just normal social interaction.

You will find no injunctions against manipulation in the Scripture. In fact, God is a shameless master of manipulation.

We call manipulation evil because by doing so, we do not have to face the question of whether the manipulator’s motives are evil or good, or if someone is attempting to push us towards something that is evil or good. In short, the sin of manipulation is an imaginary construct that exists solely to justify cowardice.


One thought on “You’re twisting my arm, here…

  1. edhartshorn says:

    Chew on this, monkey. sin = selfishness. “evil manipulation” is done out of selfishness. The rules don’t apply to God, because He IS God, so He cannot be guilty of manipulation. We have to live within the framework He built for us, but He lives outside that framework.

    Manipulation is “evil” if it is done out of selfishness. If it is done out of love (as defined by Jesus’ life) then it is not evil and may (depending on definition) be not manipulation.

    And this word has changed meaning over time, it originally meant (and still means in some contexts) “the skillful handling of tools or objects”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s